Let’s start by defining what
<script> without any attributes does. The HTML file will be parsed until the script file is hit, at that point parsing will stop and a request will be made to fetch the file (if it’s external). The script will then be executed before parsing is resumed.
async downloads the file during HTML parsing and will pause the HTML parser to execute it when it has finished downloading.
defer downloads the file during HTML parsing and will only execute it after the parser has completed.
defer scripts are also guaranteed to execute in the order that they appear in the document.
When should I use what?
Typically you want to use
async where possible, then
defer then no attribute. Here are some general rules to follow:
- If the script is modular and does not rely on any scripts then use
- If the script relies upon or is relied upon by another script then use
- If the script is small and is relied upon by an
asyncscript then use an inline
scriptwith no attributes placed above the
IE9 and below have some pretty bad bugs in their implementation of
defer such that the execution order isn’t guaranteed. If you need to support <= IE9 I recommend not using
defer at all and include your scripts with no attribute if the execution order matters. Read the specifics here.